Is a Walk-In Shower Better Than a Bathtub?

Many homeowners don’t have to think twice about removing a tub. But what about shower-tub combinations? Built-in baths in old masters? Some are on the fence about whether or not these are worth updating during a bathroom remodel. 

Let’s answer the question right away. Is a walk-in shower better than a bathtub? Neither is better, but a shower is completely necessary. Whether or not you need a tub depends on your property. The following information can help you decide.

Walk-in shower vs. a bathtub: Key differences at a glance

You’re eventually going to need what you don’t have. Are you willing to put up with an occasional twinge of regret? Here’s a fast breakdown of walk-in showers vs. bathtubs.

The pros of a walk-in shower

If you don’t have a walk-in, you probably feel you’re missing out. In addition to the amazing tilework, built-ins, and benches you can add, they’re a daily essential in many ways.

They use up less water and space. 

The average shower can use half the water that a full bath does. You also have more flexibility with dimensions. Only tubs of a certain size can comfortably fit in a small bathroom. Even then, the location is probably already set in stone. There are far more size options with a walk-in shower.

Less maintenance, more style.

There’s nothing like a custom tile feature adorned with brass fixtures, displayed from inside a frameless glass door. This arrangement is easier to keep clean, too, as daily shower maintenance needs little more than a squeegee.

Showers are more accessible.

Tubs can be the best way to bathe when nursing certain injuries, but these occasions are (hopefully) few and far between. For daily use by people of varying abilities, showers are easier to manage. The use of bars, benches, and handheld sprayers makes a walk-in quite safe. 

The pros of keeping your bathtub

Long before humans were showering, they were soaking in a tub. Today, the bathtub isn’t used daily in many households. There are still a few great reasons to update instead of eliminate. 

Tubs are a must for kids and pets.

Spraying down a terrier or a toddler in a shower isn’t on the list of desirable evening activities for many people. The majority of potential buyers with children under six, as well as many pet owners, agree. They need a bathtub.

A long, relaxing soak never goes out of style.

Many bathtubs are inspiring in ways a shower never could be. They invite us to slow down, unwind, and recover. They offer much-needed respite from daily routines, including showering. 

They’re more affordable.

In many cases, updating a tub-shower combo is going to be far less expensive than converting to a walk-in shower. If you have both in a master, a new freestanding tub will eat up less of the budget than the shower, too.

Should I keep at least one bathtub?

Yes, it’s better to have one tub than none, particularly if you're considering resale value. If you currently have two bathtubs or more, go ahead and replace one with a walk-in shower. And remember–trends change. Tubs may be less popular now, but the tide always turns. 

Remodeling decisions are easier with a professional designer on your side.

If the battle between walk-in shower vs. bathtub is still uncertain, you likely need both. Results better than you dreamed of are possible when you consult a professional bathroom designer. Your Local Designery connects you to custom tilework, vanities, and countertops, plus all of the fixtures and hardware you need. 

Best of all, you get expert help placing each design feature, as well as access to our trusted network of contractors and craftspeople.

“I can't recommend them enough for kitchen, bathroom, & closet organization projects. I look forward to working with them again!”

Marci, The Designery client

Bring your bathroom remodeling challenges to us. Your consultation is free.