Bathtub vs. Walk-In Shower – Which One Should You Choose?

When planning a bathroom remodel, deciding between a bathtub and a walk-in shower can feel overwhelming. Both options have unique advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice for your home often depends on factors like space, lifestyle, accessibility, and resale value.  

This guide will walk you through the pros and cons of bathtubs vs. walk-in showers and help you determine which option fits your needs. Whether you’re looking for luxurious indulgence or practical efficiency, let’s explore the possibilities and make your decision easier. 

Bathtub Pros and Cons 

Pros of a Bathtub 

1. Relaxation & Luxury 

There’s nothing quite like soaking in a hot bath after a long day. Bathtubs provide a spa-like experience, making them perfect for homeowners seeking relaxation. If self-care is part of your routine, a soaking tub might be your ultimate escape. 

2. Great for Families with Kids 

Bathtubs are a lifesaver for families with young children. Bath time is much easier when you can fill a tub and safely wash a toddler, rather than wrestling with a handheld shower head. 

3. Boosts Home Value 

Homes with at least one bathtub appeal to a broader market of future buyers. If you’re thinking about resale value, having a tub in your home could make it more desirable. 

4. Variety of Styles 

From elegant clawfoot tubs to modern whirlpool options, bathtubs come in various designs to suit any style. Make a bold statement with a freestanding tub or opt for a classic alcove installation. 

Cons of a Bathtub 

1. Takes Up Space 

Bathtubs require more room, making them less ideal for smaller bathrooms. In compact spaces, fitting a tub might mean sacrificing storage or valuable floor area. 

2. Higher Water Usage 

Filling a tub can use significantly more water than a quick shower. If eco-friendliness or lower water bills are a priority, this could be a concern. 

3. Mobility Challenges 

Getting in and out of a bathtub can be difficult for older adults or individuals with mobility issues. It’s worth considering whether a walk-in shower might offer easier accessibility. 

Walk-In Shower Pros and Cons 

Pros of a Walk-In Shower 

1. Space-Saving & Modern 

If you’re working with a small bathroom, a walk-in shower opens up the space and provides a sleek, minimalistic look. Say goodbye to cramped layouts and hello to airy designs. 

2. Easier Accessibility 

For aging homeowners or families planning for the future, a walk-in shower is the ideal choice. Step-free entries and customizable grab bars improve safety and allow for long-term independence. 

3. Low Maintenance & Easy Cleaning 

With no tub basin to scrub and fewer crevices for mold and mildew, walk-in showers are much easier to keep clean. This means less time scrubbing and more time enjoying your bathroom. 

4. Water Efficiency 

Walk-in showers generally use less water than filling a bathtub, especially when equipped with low-flow showerheads. Being eco-friendly has never looked so good. 

Cons of a Walk-In Shower 

1. Not Ideal for Families with Young Kids 

Unlike tubs, walk-in showers aren’t suitable for bathing small children. This can be a dealbreaker for families with toddlers or young kids. 

2. Lower Resale Appeal 

Potential buyers often prefer homes with at least one bathtub. While sleek showers are trendy, skipping a tub entirely may impact your walk-in shower resale value. 

3. Cold & Splashing 

Open designs can sometimes allow water to escape onto the floor. Without proper insulation or a thoughtfully designed enclosure, walk-in showers may feel colder or create messes. 

Key Factors to Consider 

When deciding between a bathtub and a walk-in shower, several personal and practical factors come into play: 

1. Bathroom Size & Layout

• Small bathrooms benefit more from a walk-in shower, as it saves space and creates an illusion of openness.  

• Larger bathrooms can comfortably fit both a bathtub and a shower, offering the best of both worlds. 

2. Lifestyle & Daily Routine

• Do you enjoy long, relaxing baths as part of your self-care? A soaking tub could elevate that experience. 

• Prefer a quick, efficient way to start your day? A walk-in shower might better suit your needs. 

3. Future Needs & Accessibility

• Consider aging-in-place or multi-generational living when choosing your remodel layout. 

• If accessibility is a priority, a walk-in shower is an excellent long-term investment to ensure safety and independence. 

4. Resale Value & Market Trends

• If you plan to sell your home, note that a combination of both a bathtub and a shower often appeals to the widest range of buyers. 

• Still debating? Research local housing trends to see what buyers in your area prefer for bathroom layouts. 

Transform Your Bathroom with Confidence 

Ultimately, the choice between a bathtub and a walk-in shower depends on your unique needs and lifestyle. For those fortunate enough to have ample space, a combination of both can give you the best of both worlds. Imagine unwinding in a luxurious soaking tub on the weekends while using a modern, functional walk-in shower for your daily routine. 

If space or budget constraints make choosing one necessary, weigh the factors mentioned above carefully. Regardless of your choice, a thoughtfully designed remodel can elevate your home’s aesthetic and functionality, adding long-term value to your investment. 

Not sure which option is right for you? Our experts at The Designery are here to help! Contact us today, and we’ll guide you through the decision-making process and bring your dream bathroom to life.